Edgar vs AuthoredUp: honest comparison
Edgar and AuthoredUp solve the LinkedIn content challenge from opposite angles. Edgar removes writing from the equation entirely by turning voice conversations into posts. AuthoredUp makes you a better LinkedIn writer with formatting tools, templates, analytics, and a drafts library. One replaces writing; the other enhances it.
Where Edgar is stronger
- +No writing required, ideal for people who have ideas but struggle to put them into words
- +Faster content creation: 10-15 minutes of conversation produces 2-3 posts
- +Posts capture your natural voice and thinking, not templated structures
- +Works independently, no need to learn formatting tricks or writing techniques
Where AuthoredUp is stronger
- +Rich text formatting and preview tools that work right inside LinkedIn
- +Extensive template library and post analytics help you improve your writing over time
- +Very affordable, significantly lower price point for people who enjoy writing
Feature-by-feature comparison
| Feature | Edgar | AuthoredUp |
|---|---|---|
| Content creation method | Voice conversation with AI | Enhanced writing editor with templates |
| Writing required | None, you talk | Yes, you write, it helps you format |
| LinkedIn integration | Publishes to LinkedIn | Chrome extension inside LinkedIn |
| Post analytics | Not available | Detailed post performance tracking |
| Content templates | AI adapts to your voice automatically | 200+ curated post templates |
| Pricing | From $85/mo | From $19.95/mo |
The verdict
Choose Edgar if writing is the bottleneck. You have plenty of ideas but never get around to writing them down. Choose AuthoredUp if you enjoy writing and want tools to make your posts look better, perform better, and take less time to format. AuthoredUp is a great fit for natural writers; Edgar is built for people who'd rather talk.
Edgar is ideal for
Professionals with deep expertise who don't enjoy or have time for writing
AuthoredUp is ideal for
Active LinkedIn writers who want better formatting, templates, and post analytics
Frequently asked questions
- Can I use Edgar and AuthoredUp together?
- You could, but there's not much overlap. Edgar produces finished posts from voice conversations, so there's less need for AuthoredUp's formatting and template tools. If you sometimes want to write posts yourself and sometimes use voice, using both could make sense.
- Is Edgar worth the higher price compared to AuthoredUp?
- They solve very different problems. AuthoredUp at ~$20/mo helps you write better posts. Edgar at $85/mo creates posts for you from voice conversations. If you don't enjoy writing, Edgar's price reflects the time it saves. If you like writing, AuthoredUp is the better value.
- Which tool produces better LinkedIn posts?
- It depends on the user. A skilled writer with AuthoredUp's templates can produce excellent posts. Edgar produces posts that sound naturally like you because they come from your actual words. The quality ceiling may be higher with AuthoredUp for great writers, but Edgar's floor is higher for non-writers.
Other ai writing tools
Edgar vs Taplio
Honest comparison of Edgar and Taplio for LinkedIn content. Edgar uses voice conversations; Taplio offers AI writing, scheduling, and growth tools.
Edgar vs Supergrow
Compare Edgar and Supergrow for LinkedIn content creation. Both offer voice features, but Edgar is voice-first while Supergrow pairs Postcast with AI writing.
Edgar vs MagicPost
Compare Edgar and MagicPost for LinkedIn post creation. Edgar uses voice conversations; MagicPost generates posts from text prompts and templates.
Ready to find your voice?
Talk once a week, post all week long. Edgar turns a single conversation into LinkedIn posts that sound exactly like you.