Edgar writes your LinkedIn posts from a 10-minute weekly call. Talk once, post all week, in your own voice.
Try Edgar freeWhere Edgar is stronger
- +Voice conversations capture nuance and personality that text prompts miss
- +No prompt engineering needed, you have a natural conversation about your expertise
- +Posts are built from your actual words and ideas, not generated from a topic keyword
- +Guided interview draws out insights you might not think to write about on your own
Where MagicPost is stronger
- +Faster for quick, one-off posts when you know exactly what you want to say
- +Can generate posts from URLs, making it easy to repurpose existing content
- +Much lower price point makes it accessible for casual LinkedIn users
Feature-by-feature comparison
| Feature | Edgar | MagicPost |
|---|---|---|
| Content creation method | Voice conversation with AI interviewer | Text prompts and URL-to-post AI |
| Post authenticity | High, based on your actual words | Moderate, AI-generated from prompts |
| LinkedIn publishing | Built-in scheduling & publishing | Copy to clipboard |
| Input required from you | 10-15 min voice conversation | A topic, prompt, or URL |
| Posts per session | 2-3 per conversation | 1 per generation |
| Pricing | From $49/mo | Free tier available; paid from ~$15/mo |
The verdict
Choose Edgar if you want posts that genuinely sound like you and you're willing to invest in a voice-based workflow. Choose MagicPost if you want a quick, affordable way to generate LinkedIn posts from prompts and don't mind editing the output to add your personal touch. MagicPost is great for getting started; Edgar is designed for building a consistent, authentic presence.
Edgar is ideal for
Professionals who want authentic, voice-driven LinkedIn content on a consistent schedule
MagicPost is ideal for
Casual LinkedIn users who want a quick, affordable way to generate post drafts
Frequently asked questions
Other ai writing tools
Edgar vs Taplio
Honest comparison of Edgar and Taplio for LinkedIn content. Edgar uses voice conversations; Taplio offers AI writing, scheduling, and growth tools.
Edgar vs Supergrow
Compare Edgar and Supergrow for LinkedIn content creation. Both offer voice features, but Edgar is voice-first while Supergrow pairs Postcast with AI writing.
Edgar vs AuthoredUp
Compare Edgar and AuthoredUp for LinkedIn content. Edgar creates posts from voice; AuthoredUp enhances your LinkedIn writing with formatting and analytics.
Ready to find your voice?
One conversation a week. That's all it takes.
Get 3 posts that sound like you